Best Pizza in Las Vegas According to Barstool Sports Founder Dave Portnoy

Barstool Pizza Reviews in Las Vegas

Barstool Pizza Reviews in Las Vegas

If you like Pizza, then you probably already know about One Bite Pizza reviews. Dave Portnoy, the iconic founder of Barstool Sports, rates and reviews pizza places across the country. He's racked up millions of views on the One Bite Pizza Review YouTube Channel with this series and he's developed a cult following of pizza lovers.

As a degenerate gambler, Dave Portnoy aka El Pres aka Davey Pageviews, spends a lot of time in Las Vegas. While in Las Vegas, he has tried a lot of our local pizza places. I tried to use the One Bite app to create this list, but the information was incorrect, so I manually watched every video again to be sure the information is/was accurate.

One Bite Pizza Reviews in Las Vegas

Here's a collection of the pizza he's reviewed in Las Vegas. I'm starting with the worst and working towards the best. Let's go!

Encore Beach Club

El Pres is the pizza king, and that means that no matter where/when/how pizza ends up in front of him, he will take one bite and he will score it. The top comment on this video is "Pres gets tan like a homeless person" and I've never looked at homeless people the same.

  • Dave's Score: 1.4
  • Address: 3131 S Las Vegas Blvd South, Las Vegas, NV 89109

Snacks Pizza

El Pres reviews Snacks Pizza from the Bellagio Resort and Casino with the Owner of the New England Patriots Robert Kraft.

  • Dave's Score: 2.4
  • Robert Kraft's Score: 5
  • Address: 3600 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109

Sammy's Woodfired Pizza & Grill

Due to a flight delay, Dave is stuck in the Las Vegas Airport reviewing garbage pizza from Sammy's Woodfired Pizza.

  • Dave's Score: 2.4
  • Address:

Secret Pizza

El Pres reviews Secret Pizza at The Cosmopolitan in Las Vegas to tip off his birthday celebration weekend. Dave hated this pizza. He's mentioned how bad it was in every pizza review that he's done after reviewing Secret Pizza.

  • Dave's Score: 3.4
  • Address: 3708 Las Vegas Blvd S Level 3, The Boulevard Tower, Las Vegas, NV 89109

Las Vegas Motor Speedway Tailgate

Dave does a pizza review of a homemade pizza from a Las Vegas Motor Speedway Tailgate.

  • Dave's Score: 5.3
  • Address: 7000 Las Vegas Blvd N, Las Vegas, NV 89115

Evel Pie

El Pres reviews Evel Pie by himself in Las Vegas following one of his many, many meetings. Where's Frankie? Where's the editing?

  • Dave's Score: 5.9
  • Address: 508 Fremont St, Las Vegas, NV 89101

Five50 Pizza Bar

El Pres searches for the best pizza joint in Vegas and stops at the critically acclaimed FIVE50 Pizza Bar inside the Aria Resort & Casino.

  • Dave's Score: 6.2
  • Address: 3730 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109

Naked City Pizza Shop

El Pres continues his pursuit of Sin City's best  pizza joint with a try of Naked City Pizza Shop, which is WAY off the strip.

  • Dave's Score: 5.6
  • Address: 3240 S Arville St, Las Vegas, NV 89102

Best Pizza in Las Vegas

Now that we're in the 6/10 score range, we can declare the following pizza places as the best pizza in Las Vegas. Do you agree with Dave's score for the following pies in Las Vegas? Let's find out. His score might surprise you.

New York Pizzeria

El Pres promised to hit every single pizza joint in New York, and that's just what he is doing...even in Vegas! Pres and Frankie stop by New York-New York to try the New York Pizzeria on the Las Vegas Strip. Pres walked in rocking the Big Baller Brand, so I think they charged him tourist pricing with his $16 slice and water combo.

  • Dave's Score: 6.1
  • Address: 3790 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109

Pizza Rock

El Pres continues his prawl of Las Vegas for the best pizza joint in sin city and gets high recommendations for Pizza Rock in Old Vegas.

  • Dave's Score: 6.9 (first slice)
  • Dave's Score: 7.3 (second slice)
  • Address: Downtown Grand, 201 N 3rd St, Las Vegas, NV 89101

Becca's Restaurant & Lounge

2022 is a new year and a new opportunity for Dave to review new pizza places in Las Vegas. On his most recent trip to Sin City, he stopped by Becca's Restaurant and Lounge.

  • Dave's Score: 6.9
  • Address: 12656 Southern Highlands Pkwy Suite A, Las Vegas, NV 89141

Side Piece Pizza

Dave earned his views here. He's wearing a crop top and he was kicked out of the Palms Casino while recording this pizza review. He actually gave them an impressive score as they were tossing him out.

  • Dave's Score: 7.4
  • Address: 4321 W Flamingo Rd, Las Vegas, NV 89103

Cugino's Italian Deli and Pizza

While he is the most tired, run down man in Las Vegas, that doesn't stop Dave from finding his favorite pizza spot in the desert so far.

  • Dave's Score: 7.7
  • Address: 4550 S Maryland Pkwy #20, Las Vegas, NV 89119

Carmine's Pizza Kitchen

Well would you look at that, while in Las Vegas for the Canelo fight, Mr. Portnoy gave his second best score in the Las Vegas Valley. Carmine's Pizza Kitchen in Henderson (Horizon Ridge Location) claims the number two spot on our list.

  • Dave's Score: 7.3
  • Address: 2520 W Horizon Ridge Pkwy, Henderson, NV 89052

Good Pie

Dave is in Vegas for the Pizza Convention, but ended up at Good Pie instead. I'm not sure if it was the lack of sleep, but Dave was feeling Good Pie. He gave the Grandma pizza a 7.9 and then took a hot steaming dump all over secret pizza.

  • Dave's Score: 7.9
  • Address: 725 S Las Vegas Blvd #140, Las Vegas, NV 89101


Well folks, that's all the pizza reviews we have for you. Barstool Sports founder, Dave Portnoy has unofficially crowned Good Pie as the king of the Las Vegas pizza scene. I really think Cugino's is one of the best pizzas in Las Vegas, but that's besides the point. Do you agree? Do you disagree? Let us know! Looking for the complete guide to Las Vegas food? We wrote about this for you. Looking for the best BBQ in Las Vegas? We have a guide on that too. Until next time!